| Year | Champion | Second Place | Third Place |
| 2014 | Stefani Deschner | Veronica Thornton | Cyndi Lucente & Rhiannon Harvey |
| 2013 | Stefani Deschner | Rhiannon Harvey | Veronica Thornton & Simone Unwalla |
| 2012 | Stefani Deschner | Phoebe Caplin | Dorothy Carney & Cyndi Lucente |
| 2011 | Phoebe Caplin | Jenna Robinson | Jennifer Lin & Anya Michaelsen |
| 2010 | Cyndi Lucente | Sophie Caplin | Victoria Thornton & Christine Bush |
| 2009 | Dee Hayes | Helen Mayes | Jenna Robinson & Victoria Owens |
| 2008 | & | ||
| 2007 | Lydia Pappas | Cyndi Lucente | Sicilia Englert & Dorothy Carney |
| 2006 | Cyndi Lucente | Sarah Klam | Lydia Pappas & Katie Heinzen |
| 2005 | Cyndi Lucente | Dorothy Carney | Rebecca Chung & Megan Huffman |
| 2004 | Diane Ferguson | Cyndi Lucente | Erin McMulliln & Sofia Wicker |
| 2003 | Diane Ferguson | Cyndi Lucente | Elizabeth Conley & Ellen Hatch |
| 2002 | Diane Ferguson | Allison Schwartz | Cyndi Lucente & Mattie Condray |
| 2001 | Diane Ferguson | Pam Schneider | Elizabeth Conley |
| 2000 | Diane Ferguson | Hollie Noble | Sicilia Chinn & Angela Leffel |
| 1999 | Diane Ferguson | Sicilia Chinn | Cyndi Carroll & Hollie Noble |
| 1998 | Sicilia Chinn | Kim Yasutis | Pam Schneider |
| 1997 | Diane Ferguson | Gigi Carter | Charlene Dimiceli |
| 1996 | Diane Ferguson | Sicilia Chinn | Charlene Dimiceli |
| 1995 | Diane Ferguson | Jeanine Prokop | Charlene Dimiceli |
| 1994 | Diane Ferguson | Charlene Dimiceli | |
| 1993 | Charlene Dimiceli | Diane Ferguson | |
| 1992 | Aimée Rinker | ||
| 1991 | Aimée Rinker | ||
| 1990 | Aimée Rinker |