| Year | Champion | Second Place | Third Place |
| 2014 | Maria Papadopoulos | Veronica Wesser | Emily Lien & Sarah Simmons |
| 2013 | Rosalie Purvis | Emily Lien | Maria Papadopoulos & Sarah Simmons |
| 2012 | Emily Lien | Sarah Simmons | Sophie Caplin & Rachel Janis |
| 2011 | Dee Hayes | Helen Mays | Christine Feagans & Emily Lien |
| 2010 | Sarah Deans | Emily Lien | Sophie Caplin & Sara Moore |
| 2009 | Sarah Deans | Eliy Lien | Sarah Moore & Sophie Caplin |
| 2009 | Sarah Deans | Melinda Toth | Kendra Sievers & Dee Hayes |
| 2008 | & | ||
| 2007 | Nadia Eldeib | Macy Lau | Michelle Sutherland |
| 2006 | Beth Larson | Cyndi Lucente | Sue Mahon & Allison Schwartz |
| 2005 | Beth Larson | Nancy Bowden | Sue Mahon & Elizabeth Casano |
| 2004 | Beth Larson | Jess Knoch | Cyndi Lucente & Brighid Moret |
| 2003 | Anja Kueddelsmann | Allison Schwartz | Brighid Moret |
| 2002 | Brighid Tewey | Allison Schwartz | Diane Ferguson & Cyndi Lucente |
| 2001 | Jennifer Buck | Anja Kueddelsmann | Angela Leffel |
| 2000 | Diane Ferguson | Angela Leffel | Angie Hunter & Hollie Noble |
| 1999 | Allison Schwartz | Mary Anne Walker | Vicki Karousos |
| 1998 | Kim Yasutis | Cyndi Carroll | Stephanie Liskey |
| 1997 | Kim Yasutis | Diane Ferguson | Charlene DiMicelli |
| 1996 | Charlene Dimiceli | Diane Ferguson | Mary Daniels |
| 1995 | Charlene Dimiceli | Diane Ferguson | (no third place) |
| 1994 | Charlene Dimiceli | Diane Ferguson | |
| 1993 | Jackie Serbu | Beth Smart | Diane Ferguson |
| 1992 | Beth Smart | Aimée Rinker | Diane Ferguson |
| 1991 | Diane Ferguson | Aimée Rinker | Jackie Serbu |
| 1990 | Aimée Rinker | Cindy Storer | Diane Ferguson |
| 1989 | |||
| 1988 | Beth Smart | Aimée Rinker | Beth Glover |